Skip to content

Less wine, more gym…

News items telling the public that drinking alcohol has health benefits are a regular feature of the tabloid press, and once again the other week I spotted this news item making it’s way around on social media:
“Glass of Red Wine Equals 1 Hour at Gym, New Study Says”

My goal in this post is not to ‘bash alcohol consumption’ specifically, but just to highlight how scientific facts become distorted by the time they find their way into the mainstream press.

The news article linked above clearly attempts to inform the reader that drinking red wine is so good for your heart, that it’s as good as exercise. Of course, if we read down a little way, we find the message is slightly less clear…the research lead is noted as saying that a compound found in red wine, resveratrol, can have positive benefits on your heart and other muscles which may be beneficial for those who cannot exercise. He stresses that for those physically incapable of exercise, a glass of red wine may be beneficial alongside what little exercise they can manage.

So here we have a classic example of how a researcher has made a suggestion that “may offer some benefit” to a specific ‘special population’ but by the time it reaches the popular press, the headline is “Glass of Red Wine Equals 1 Hour at Gym, New Study Says” with no mention of “might” or “for those who are physically incapable of exercise” and the short article is accompanied by a picture of red wine being poured, captioned with the words “Glass of red wine equals 1 hour at gym.”

Clearly, this is somewhat stretching the truth - to suggest to the population at large that they will somehow derive the same benefits from sitting at home drinking wine, as they would from going to the gym and working out for an hour. How ridiculous!


So what is this compound, resveratrol?
You can read a little about it hear on Wikipedia.

Resveratrol is a compound found in the skin of the grapes they use to make wine. In the grape skin, the resveratrol is found in much higher concentrations…so why not publish an article saying “eating grapes can benefit your heart” - that would surely be better health advice to give to the general public, yes? In a society wrestling with an obesity epidemic, would that not be more responsible journalism?

If you read the notes under the ‘Adverse Effects’ and ‘Research’ headings on that Wiki page, you’ll see that resveratrol is far from being a “wonder drug to cure all our ills” as there is very little evidence to suggest it has any substantial beneficial effects whatsoever, and evidence suggests that isolating the compound and producing it as a medical supplement, had more side effects than benefits.

No safe limit

Far from suggesting that drinking red wine offers you the same benefits as working out for an hour in the gym, in reality, as more research is done, so safe limits for alcohol consumption are likely to come down. Earlier this year, new research came to light showing that there is truly no safe limit to alcohol consumption - even very moderate consumption, and the stress-busting benefits that may offer, comes with some risk.

As this article notes “The guidelines are to say there is no safe alcohol limit and even drinking small amounts could cause illnesses including cancer.”

By comparison to quaffing down a glass of red wine, an hour at the gym offers many benefits, for all people, at whatever level of physical ability they may be.

If you want to explore this subject in more depth, please visit this page and read the Mother Nature’s Diet official Stance on Alcohol.

Irresponsible journalism

As I wrote at the start, the point of this post is not to bash alcohol consumption, it is to bash bad journalism! The problem is, many people do not read the article, and very few read it and then do some research, looking for the science behind the article, or looking for either supporting, or opposing, evidence. What invariably happens is that people scrolling through their social media news stream see a picture of red wine, with the words ‘Glass of Red Wine Equals 1 Hour at Gym, New Study Says’ and the item appears to be a legitimate newspaper item, shared to a wide audience. They take it at face value, and they click ‘Share’ adding something like “See, all this exercise isn’t important, I’m sticking with my red wine! All things are good for you in moderation.” I see this sort of thing every day.

It’s not true, all things are not good for you in moderation.

  • Try drinking a moderate sized glass of bleach and tell me that’s good for you. (Please don’t!)
  • Try stabbing yourself in the leg with a moderately sized knife and tell me if that’s good for you. (Again, please don’t!)
  • Try jumping off a moderate height cliff without a rope or parachute and see if that’s good for you. (No! Don’t!)

In truth, the cliche ‘All things are good for you in moderation’ is just a saying, made up and used to fit with what people want it to fit to, like having a glass of red wine every night.

I have nothing against moderate alcohol consumption. If you like one or two glasses of red wine on a Friday or Saturday night to end the week, good for you, that’s OK by me. But if you fail to exercise on a regular basis, and then you drink a glass or two of red wine every night, don’t go kidding yourself that it’s a healthy lifestyle, and you’ve got the balance just right. That just is not true.

More gym, less wine, and you’ll derive far more heart-healthy benefits.

3 Comments Post a comment
  1. Age MacKenzie #

    I prefer to apply the ‘all things in moderation are good for you’ misnomer to thing that ARE beneficial…like exercise, as opposed to using it as a justification for partaking in things that you know in your heart of hearts are bad for you. So, if you exercise and it dawns on you that you actually feel bloody amazing it is quite possible to end up ‘over-exercising’. Might seem an unlikely scenario to none exercisers right now but believe me, you will get the bug…feeling amazing is, well, amazing. But too much of a good thing can be detrimental. More is not necessarily better. Great article again Karl.

    December 24, 2021
  2. More gym less wine should be a NHS New Years resolution for us all

    December 24, 2021

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Stop reading crap in The Daily Fail! | MotherNaturesDiet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: